The Charlotte News

Tuesday, April 17, 1951

FOUR EDITORIALS

Site Ed. Note: The front page reports, via Olen Clements, that allied troops had hit Communist forces in the battle for Hwachon dam after an enemy man-made smoke screen hindered allied progress for awhile in the late afternoon, permitting allied war planes to drop napalm, rockets and machine gun fire. Censorship prevented disclosure of the size and exact location of the enemy. The object of the attack was to throw off balance the planned enemy spring offensive.

On the western front, the allies maintained pressure south of Chorwon. Yonchon, on the road leading northwest to Chorwon, was evacuated by the enemy.

New Eighth Army ground commander, Lt. General James Van Fleet, visited the troops on the western front.

The GOP policy committee approved a plan of Senator Homer Ferguson to have a joint committee broadly to investigate Far Eastern policy.

In a speech prepared for delivery to the National Association of Radio and Television Broadcasters, Joint Chiefs chairman General Omar Bradley said that General MacArthur's policies with respect to China and Korea could have precipitated world war three and that the intervention in Korea in June had likely prevented such a war, being planned then by the Soviets, in Indo-China, Thailand, and Formosa. He said that the war might be headed to stalemate but also could be concluded honorably. He found that the use made thus far by China of air bases in Manchuria had not warranted their bombing. He also said that the U.S. would not engage in preventive war or appeasement and that attempt to end the war by ultimatum of bombing Russia would be impracticable and potentially create backlash. His speech, per Administration directive, had been cleared first by the State Department.

The President canceled plans for Thursday to address the American Society of Newspaper Editors, so as not to interfere with General MacArthur's address to Congress.

The House formally invited the General to speak at 12:30 p.m. on Thursday, after the Senate, by unanimous consent, agreed to the joint session.

In San Francisco, the city awaited the arrival of General MacArthur, who had requested that initial greetings be limited to formalities of brief military honors. The next day, the General would ride in a motorcade through the streets.

The British submarine Affray, with 75 men and officers aboard, vanished during maneuvers in the English Channel. The U.S. Navy began assisting in the search for the submarine. It was considered possible that the commander had misread his orders regarding his time for reporting in the morning and might still be proceeding submerged. The last submarine disaster for England had been in January, 1950 when the Truculent was rammed by a Swedish tanker and sank in the Thames estuary, costing the lives of 64 of 79 aboard.

The Senate Banking Committee ordered an investigation into whether members of Congress had engaged in influence peddling in providing RFC loans to businesses. The investigation would be performed by the same subcommittee, chaired by Senator John McClellan, which had performed the previous RFC investigation.

In Greensboro, management and TWUA union leaders charged each other with causing violence which had erupted in Durham, where a female textile worker's house was bombed, though without injury to any person, and in Danville, Va., where a shooting of a striker and tear gassing had taken place at the Dan River Mills.

Tom Fesperman of The News, in the second in his series of five articles on the problems faced by families in Mecklenburg County, describes testimony of a woman in Domestic Relations Court, who said that her husband had beaten her with flailing, pounding fists, to which her husband replied, "That's right." She said he had told her not to talk back to him when he was drinking because he got mean. The store had repossessed some of their furniture and he began drinking in the afternoon, after which she began fussing at him and so he hit her. He was also mean to their three children sometimes and so she put them in another home. The husband confirmed the testimony. The judge recommended he consult Alcoholics Anonymous over his drinking problem but the man said he could quit on his own. The woman said the couple had known each other a month before marriage and that she had loved him but stopped a few months earlier.

The judge sentenced the man temporarily to jail until he could get an alcohol rehabilitation counselor to see him. He told Mr. Fesperman afterward that it was a typical case, involving one of the major causes of domestic disturbances.

"The Edge of Night" will continue after this brief commercial message.

In the fourteenth installment of Dale Carnegie's How To Stop Worrying and Start Living, he extends advice to housewives on combating fatigue.

On the editorial page, "The Area of Agreement" points out that amid the debate between those favoring the dismissal of General MacArthur and those opposed, there remained areas of basic agreement, that Soviet Russia was the principal seat of Communism, which could not be stripped of potency until Russia was defeated or checked, that it was better to have allies in peace or war than to be left to live or fight alone, that it was of first priority to protect physical security of the nation and then to protect and expand freedom wherever it existed or could exist elsewhere, that possibilities for peace always had to be explored fully, that if war came it should be fought on the country's terms, and that if democracy was to remain free, final authority over military and diplomatic policy had to reside with the duly elected civilian government.

"A Sound Fiscal Measure" finds salutary the resolution introduced by Senator Harry F. Byrd and 46 other Senators, to return to the omnibus appropriations bill used in 1950, but abandoned during this session of Congress in favor of the old system of piecemeal appropriation. The piece favors the resolution as it would place the burden on Congress to develop a balanced budget and provide the public with a clear picture of spending.

"A Challenge to Charlotteans" tells of Senator Estes Kefauver, in an interview with U.S. News & World Report, suggesting that unless the people demanded that something be done about organized crime, no amount of local or Federal legislation would do much to eradicate it. He said that Governor Adlai Stevenson of Illinois had testified that the causes for poor law enforcement were corruption, improper campaign contributions, inadequate staffing in law enforcement and prosecutors' offices, lack of knowledge, and public indifference. Senator Kefauver added that it resulted from public apathy.

It challenges the citizens of Charlotte accordingly.

"Who Gave These Orders?" wonders who ordered the Air Force police to prevent press photographers by force from photographing General MacArthur, a newsworthy figure, when he landed at Hickam Field in Hawaii. It suggests that the public should know whether General MacArthur issued such orders or someone else to make the General look bad.

Drew Pearson tells of Congressional Republicans in private not being as outspokenly for General MacArthur or opposed to the President as they were in public, that they were concerned that their ardor could backfire and cause the public to believe that the Republican leaders favored a third world war. Congressman Jacob Javits of New York said that while General MacArthur ought be heard before Congress, to tell his side, it should not be conveyed to the public that the GOP believed that military leaders could dictate to civilian authorities.

GOP House Leader Joe Martin rejected the idea of impeaching the President, saying that they did not have the votes and that the basis would be hard to prove. Other Republicans feared that the General might be subjected to court-martial if he attacked the President in his speech to Congress on Thursday, and might also contribute to national disunity. Others believed he could speak with impunity under the First Amendment.

Congressman Carl Vinson, chairman of the House Armed Services Committee, received word of the MacArthur firing at 1:00 a.m the prior Wednesday, before it hit the newspapers. General Omar Bradley called and said he would read the statement, to which Mr. Vinson gruffly protested because of the hour, then thanked the General and went back to bed.

Senator Joseph McCarthy had claimed that the firing was prompted by midnight "bourbon and benedictine". Yet, in March, 1948, when the General was running in the Wisconsin Republican primary, the Senator from Wisconsin addressed a letter to thousands of his constituents, telling them the General was ready for retirement and was too old to be President, that he was born in Little Rock, Ark., not Wisconsin, did not vote in Wisconsin, that neither of his two marriages or his intervening divorce had been in Wisconsin and that neither of the wives had ever resided there at any time.

Administration leaders in Congress were privately complaining that the President might have timed his firing of the General better, at a time when Democratic prestige was not already suffering, with the Kefauver organized crime investigation and the RFC investigation still fresh in the public mind, or that he should at least stop cussing out Senators on the phone in debating the subject. White House advisers stated that a long overdue cleanup of the administration was occurring, with Mrs. Merl Young, who had received the fur coat allegedly to obtain influence from her husband in obtaining an RFC loan, and that White House aide Donald Dawson would be next, unless he cleared himself in his testimony regarding alleged influence on loans.

Joseph Alsop, in Tehran, discusses the extreme seriousness of the instability in Iran following nationalization of the oil. The entire Middle East was likewise unstable. If no compromise were found on the oil problem, the situation could be duplicated throughout the oil-producing states. Britain could lose all of its oil supply with consequent economic disaster, and interruption of Middle Eastern oil supplies would prove disastrous to all of Western Europe.

Britain was committed to rebuilding its positions economically in the world and was, if necessary, going to implement a plan the Cabinet had developed during the first Iranian oil crisis of 1946, when it prepared for occupation of southern Iran to protect the oil from encroachment by the Soviets putting pressure in northern Iran, in Azerbaijan. If the British were to occupy part of Iran, the rest inevitably would be occupied by the Soviets under a 1921 treaty. Any effort to take over the oil companies would have a destabilizing ripple effect through the whole region, resulting in chaos.

If Middle Eastern airbases were lost to the U.S., it would be tantamount to loss of at least half the American Strategic Air Force.

The nationalists in Iran were not consciously playing to the Soviets at the expense of the West, but were rather comparable to the isolationists in the U.S., such as Senator Kenneth Wherry, unable to see beyond the ends of their noses.

The problem could be solved, provided the British stopped behaving as if it were business as usual prior to World War II, and provided the U.S. began more creative thinking regarding the region.

Bertram Benedict writes of the analogy between the firing of General MacArthur by President Truman and the firing of General George McClellan by President Lincoln. General McClellan had been made commander of the Army of the Potomac after the rout by the Confederates at Bull Run. He then postponed an attack by the Army until President Lincoln ordered it on February 22, 1862, then disobeyed the President by delaying until March and only advancing slowly at that time, meeting reverses. He complained to the President and Secretary of War Edwin Stanton that the Government was not providing the necessary troops to achieve victory. Before the end of the year, the President dismissed him because he moved too slowly.

General McCellan, however, remained popular with the public and press and was nominated by the Democrats for the presidency in 1864, and after being handily defeated by the President, eventually became Governor of New Jersey.

His troubles in 1862 came primarily from reliance on bad intelligence which had overstated the strength of Lee's Army of Northern Virginia.

The editors note that Robert C. Ruark had been ill for several days, as he had recently commented, himself, and that his column would return upon his recovery.

Send him a "get well soon" card.

A letter writer from Kew Gardens, N.Y., favors General MacArthur for President and Senator Taft for Vice-President on the "Republican Reformed" ticket.

A letter from Riverside, California, finds that it would have been better to have thrown out the whole Administration than to fire General MacArthur, expresses disappointment at the News editorial on the subject.

A letter writer from Davidson College finds the newspaper performing a disservice to the country in its editorial of April 11 and the Dowling editorial cartoon of April 12, regarding the student deferment issue, making it difficult to have a well-trained military by arousing antagonism of the non-college population against a basically good plan. He clarifies that not all college students would receive the deferment and that not all were from one class of society.

Some were not "intellectual aristocrats".

A letter writer finds the patrons of the arts in Charlotte meager in number after returning from a sparsely attended, excellent performance of the North Carolina Symphony.

A letter from the Sixth Grade of Thomasboro School thanks the newspaper for showing the students around its physical plant.

Bet they did not get to see the absquatulator at work.

Framed Edition
[Return to Links
Page by Subject] [Return to Links-Page by Date] [Return to News<i><i><i>—</i></i></i>Framed Edition]
Links-Date Links-Subj.