The Charlotte News

Monday, July 24, 1950

THREE EDITORIALS

Site Ed. Note: The front page reports that the North Korean troops had attacked behind eight tanks on Monday into the night, all along a twisting 150-mile front, stretching nearly the entire breadth of the peninsula. But, according to MacArthur headquarters in Tokyo, the U.N. defenders continued to repulse the enemy. Three of the tanks had been knocked out by 3.5-inch rocket launchers and the anti-tank crews were searching for the other five in darkness. A broad flanking threat was taking place, and the South Korean police were the only defense available against North Korean efforts near the southwest tip of the peninsula. Communist troop pressure had mounted all day against the American lines defending the Taejon-Yongdong highway.

North and northeast of Yongdong, a force of North Koreans pushed a three-speared attack on other American forces.

Hal Boyle had reported on the Yongdong front that Communist infantry at one time had penetrated behind the advanced American positions and erected a mortar-backed roadblock. But the threat had been eliminated in two hours by American tanks and artillery.

American planes and ground troops were credited with knocking out a total of five of eight enemy tanks leading about 700 infantrymen near Poun.

William R. Moore reports from a forward American command post that, according to an aide, Maj. General William F. Dean had escaped burning Taejon the previous Thursday night after leading personally a street-by-street bazooka battle against the tank-led North Koreans. The aide, who had been wounded in the battle, said that the General had not been wounded, as previously reported. He had led the attack in the city at nightfall but took a wrong turn, right into a Communist roadblock which then opened fire with machineguns, causing the General's convoy to double back, running then into other enemy forces. The force then abandoned their vehicles and sought protection across rice paddies into the hills. The General then left the party and went down the hill to pick up stragglers. The party waited two hours for his return and then departed.

General Dean had in fact been taken prisoner by the North Koreans and would not be released until the end of the war three years hence.

Members of the House Armed Services Committee called on top military leaders to provide an accounting in executive session of the 48 billion dollars spent on defense since 1947.

The U.S. sought a meeting the following day of the U.N. Security Council to hear the first report on the Korean war prepared by General MacArthur, the supreme commander of the U.N. forces.

In response to the call by Secretary-General Trygve Lie the previous week for U.N. members to provide more than moral support to the U.N. effort in Korea, Thailand offered a combat force of 4,000 men but The Netherlands said it could not contribute ground forces for the fact of "practical difficulties".

A Nationalist Chinese defense ministry spokesman told of junks having been observed, under cover of artillery barrage, approaching the island of Quemoy off the mainland China coast port of Amoy. It was thought that it was the long-anticipated invasion of the Nationalist-held bastion, utilized as a blockade base against the Communist Chinese. The spokesman said that existing garrisons on the island were adequate to resist the invading forces. Artillery had begun bombarding the town of Guanau on Quemoy the previous night. The spokesman doubted that the attack would be directly against Formosa, more than 100 miles from Quemoy.

The State Department said that the U.S. would not interfere in the situation, as the ban on fighting between the Nationalists and Communists, which would be enforced by the U.S., applied only to Formosa and the nearby Pescadores Islands.

At the Long Range Proving Ground in Coca, Fla., a two-stage "bumper" rocket was successfully launched this date in a first horizontal test firing, and was regarded as a preview of "push-button" warfare. It was the first successful launch of a rocket from the proving ground in Florida. The main part of the rocket was a captured German V-2, capped by a 700-pound Wac Corporal, which, after separation from the V-2, had an anticipated range of 250 miles.

Don't mess with those Wac Corporals.

The Army announced that it would reopen Camp Breckinridge, Ky., as a replacement training center, the second such center to be reopened since the start of the Korean war a month earlier, the other being Camp Jackson, S.C.

The President ordered the FBI to tighten its enforcement program against wartime "espionage, sabotage and subversive activities", and called on citizens to aid in the effort by reporting suspicious activities.

Senator Homer Ferguson of Michigan revealed for the first time that in 1947, General Marshall, then Secretary of State, had been informed in executive session by the Senate Appropriations Committee of a "deliberate, calculated program to protect Communist personnel in high places" within the State Department. The State Department had then replied that it would undertake action to clear such persons out of the Department. The timing of the release of the material coincided with Senator Ferguson's effort, along with other Republican Senators, to decry the Senate Foreign Relations subcommittee report approved the previous week by the full Senate, denouncing as a "hoax and a fraud" the charges by Senator Joseph McCarthy against the Department for supposedly harboring Communists. Senator Ferguson said that the memorandum to Secretary Marshall undermined the part of the approved subcommittee report which had contended that four Republican-chaired committees in 1947 had found no evidence of actionable disloyalty in the State Department.

The President spoke with Congressional leaders on the advisability of an immediate, emergency tax increase on both individual and business incomes. House Speaker Sam Rayburn said that the matter was still in the conversation stage. White House press secretary Charles G. Ross said that the President had not yet decided when he would send a tax message to Congress but that some hints of his approach might be contained in his mid-year economic message set to be provided Congress the following Wednesday.

In Myrtle Beach, S.C., an Air Force C-46 transport plane crashed and burned in nearby swampland, killing 34 servicemen aboard, thirty of whom were Tennessee Air National Guardsmen en route to Nashville for war games.

A&P pledged that it would resist unwarranted price increases on food and would cooperate with the Federal Government in the Korean war crisis.

You had better start with the coffee.

On the editorial page, "A Time for Efficiency" tells of the chairman of the Citizens Committee for the Hoover Report having urged on Senators Scott Lucas and Robert Taft that the Korean crisis had heightened the need for enacting the cost and waste reduction recommendations of the Hoover Commission. It reprints parts of the letter and urges citizens to write their Congressman and Senators to express the desire to see the Government operate more efficiently through these recommended measures.

"An Intriguing Suggestion" tells of Governor Kerr Scott, while in Greensboro recently, proposing that the State take over building and maintenance of city streets on the basis of a half-cent or three-quarter-cent gas tax increase for urban residents. No other state had undertaken such a broad responsibility for city streets and rural roads.

It hesitates to endorse the plan because the lack of local funding was the result of property tax limits having been reached in most localities, plus the State and Federal governments having taken over most of the other productive sources of revenue. It believes that a larger portion of the State highway fund should be devoted to city streets but that it should not come with another gas tax increase. It also expresses reservation about leaving to the State controls over local street projects.

The League of Municipalities plan to have the State slowly increase its allocation to cities for the purpose over a period of years appeared, finds the piece, to be the sounder approach.

"The Cost of Slums" tells of Denver having conducted a study recently of its slums, finding that though comprising less than ten percent of the land and six percent of the population, the areas required a disproportionate share of 40 percent of the general relief funds, 34 percent of funding for aid to dependent children, 32 percent of police calls, and 30 percent of the General Hospital's case load.

It finds that the results ought be of interest to Charlotte's City Administration, as it was about to pass finally a proposed urban redevelopment program, as well to the General Assembly in 1951, which had to approve receipt of the available Federal funds for the purpose.

A piece from the Durham Herald, titled "Graham's Vote on FEPC Issue", finds that Senator Frank Graham had acted consistently with his statements during the late Senate campaign lost to challenger Willis Smith, that he opposed the compulsory FEPC bill when he had recently voted against cloture of debate. He had said that he did so on the principle that debate should be unlimited, and the piece agrees with the premise while also denouncing the concept of filibuster allowing minority rule. But at the time of the cloture vote, no filibuster was proceeding.

The piece favors fair employment practices and equal opportunity of the races but finds the FEPC measure, had it passed, to have been a likely drag on progress being slowly made toward non-discrimination.

That's fine and dandy if you're white. Slow and steady wins the race. But if you're black, you want to sprint on down the track.

Drew Pearson tells of having listened to the President's speech on television and radio the previous Wednesday night regarding the Korean war, coming three weeks late, and compared it to the smooth delivery of FDR, always providing explanation and comfort to Americans immediately after a crisis had arisen, as on Monday, December 8, 1941 when he addressed Congress. President Truman seemed a sincere but inadequate man trying to do his best, compared to the "master at the helm", FDR. While the President's address helped to clear up some of the misconceptions held by Americans regarding the war, he thinks that it should have been delivered much earlier.

The President needed help badly in doing his job and so it was incumbent on Americans to pull together and unite in support of the war effort.

The Jaycees who had seen action in the last war had already undertaken to try to educate young soldiers as to what to expect and how to get ahead in the Army and Navy, and above all inform of the objectives of the war and its reasons.

The average citizen tended not to understand when and where wars began. American involvement in World War II had actually begun on September 18, 1931, when the Japanese warlords invaded Manchuria, not at Pearl Harbor. Secretary of State Henry Stimson, later Secretary of War under FDR from 1940, tried to stop the war in 1931 through the League of Nations but had failed in the endeavor. Wars usually began in segments, not suddenly at one time. Aggressors had to build up their strength to wage war effectively, and undertake it gradually to avoid as long as possible arousing the democracies to fight back. After Manchuria, Mussolini had attacked Ethiopia in late 1935 and Hitler and Mussolini had aided Franco's Insurgents against the Loyalists in the Spanish Civil War from 1936 to 1939, and then came Hitler's Anschluss in Austria in 1938 and the Munich "peace in our time" agreement regarding Czechoslovakia in September of that year, all as a prelude to the invasion of Poland in September, 1939 by Germany and the further aggression by the Japanese in Manchuria, starting in summer, 1937, beginning the Sino-Japanese war.

World War III, were it to come to pass as a hot war, he ventures, had begun when Russia grabbed Rumania, Bulgaria, Poland, Hungary and Czechoslovakia, although regarded as the beginning of the cold war. Korea was another of those segments, a part of the overall scheme of the Kremlin to Communize the world and wear down the resistance and economic wherewithal of the democracies in the process.

Sooner or later, he urges, the democracies had to draw a line against the scheme of Communist aggression and the President deserved credit for recognizing that fact. He could have waited, as FDR had, for a Pearl Harbor, that is a direct attack on the territory of the United States. But, he adds, the Russians were smart enough that, unlike Hitler and the Japanese, there would likely have been no Pearl Harbor before they were ready to conduct such a severe blow to the U.S. as to knock it out completely.

It might be added historically that other such incremental actions would be Vietnam, the Quemoy-Matsu crisis of 1958, which set forth in high relief Secretary of State John Foster Dulles's concept of "brinksmanship", the eyeball-to-eyeball strategy made most manifest in the Cuban Missile Crisis of October, 1962, another Soviet test of American resolve, this time testing further the young new President's will to contest Soviet aggression, after the start of erection of the Berlin Wall in August, 1961, following the April, 1961 failed Bay of Pigs effort, planned late during the Eisenhower Administration, to overthrow Fidel Castro in Cuba for his affinity to Moscow and willingness to receive arms from Russia, placing a Russian satellite 90 miles off the coast of Florida and, in the Crisis, providing therefore significantly shorter response time and greater accuracy to offensive medium-range and long-range nuclear ballistic missiles, thus providing the means by which the Soviets could barter, if left unchecked, the NATO protection of West Berlin and then West Germany, that sought by the Russians to be eliminated since after World War II.

While the "domino theory", which provided the rationale for both Korea and Vietnam—though Korea having started in a much different way, with U.N. denunciation of undeniable Communist aggression by the North against the South, in furtherance of a pre-existing U.S. and U.N. commitment to protection of the South's independence, as opposed to the questionable casus belli offered by the Gulf of Tonkin incidents of August, 1964 and further intensified by the Viet Cong attack on Pleiku in February, 1965—proved in the end not to be operative after the fall of South Vietnam to the Communists in 1975, a reasonable argument can be made that without the long war against the Communists there, waged first by the French through Dien Bien Phu in 1954 and then by the Americans in aid of the South Vietnamese, starting in 1965, Communist aggression might have continued in hot war elsewhere and, indeed, the dominoes in the Pacific might have begun to fall one by one, even if premised on an outmoded World War II, pre-nuclear, pre-jet, pre-rocket era concept—a concept, it might be noted, that Joseph Alsop during this period of history regularly pushed in his columns leading up to the invasion of South Korea by the North. But the counter-argument is equally sound, that the Vietnam War was, in its essentials, a local civil war waged by Ho Chi Minh's guerrilla fighters for independence of the country from foreign interests—perceived, even as to the Americans, as being imperialistic—, and not as an incremental part of the cold war. That latter argument finds its own counter, however, in the theory of Communist resolve to wear down the U.S. economically and sow the seeds of discord domestically, even if apart from the actual motives of Ho and the Viet Minh in waging that war in their native country, wanting no more part of the Chinese Communists or the Russians than of the French or the Americans.

Had the U.S. removed from South Vietnam its military advisers, as planned by President Kennedy in fall, 1963 shortly before his assassination and as recommended by Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara, to be achieved after the 1964 presidential election, would the Soviets or Communist Chinese have sought to stimulate, through the usual propaganda tools and agreement to supply arms against the "imperialist" West, Communist military aggression elsewhere, from which the U.S. could not so easily demur? Or would the refusal to take the bait in 1964 by continuing the policy to remove the advisers have worked to lessen that likelihood?

In the grip of war, however, as made plain in Errol Morris's documentary, "The Fog of War", such theoretical armchair diagnosis and laser surgery to eradicate the cancer is not easily accomplished or, generally, practicable, with the complication of potential nuclear disaster at the end of an erroneously rendered prognosis and treatment, such as much earlier withdrawal from Vietnam, prior to the mire. In other words, 20-20 hindsight is always perfect, but reasonable foresight is substantially harder to achieve when approaching relatively novel situations in novel times complicated by new weaponry. It all might seem a little fanciful with that perfect hindsight in play but the avoidance of the nuclear confrontation was uppermost in everyone's mind, and if that meant fighting relatively small, limited conventional wars occasionally, then the thinking was so be it. And who is to say that not doing so would have rendered the same result, that is the absence of nuclear confrontation?

Mr. Pearson concludes that while the President had made his negative feelings known of the columnist, having called him an "S.O.B" the previous year when Mr. Pearson criticized Presidential military aide General Harry Vaughan for accepting a medal from Argentine dictator Juan Peron, he still respected him as the President, and if some believed that he was not a strong President, it was up to the country to help him, that the citizens could not abdicate their citizenship and the responsibilities which went with it.

He says that in future columns, he would delineate the issues behind the Korean crisis.

Robert C. Ruark again, as on Saturday, looks at Hanson Baldwin's piece in the Saturday Evening Post which had contended and complained that the American fighting man in World War II had fought only to get home rather than with the moral and ideological tenacity of the Germans, Japanese, and Russians. He does not differ with Mr. Baldwin in the opinion that the Americans lacked the same zeal to die with relish as martyrs as that demonstrated by the totalitarian state soldiers. But he resents the Americans being portrayed as a "sort of Ferdinand the Bull", while praising the stoic qualities of the others.

He found, in his experience during the war in the Navy, that the Germans and Japanese were not so heroic as legend had it. He had witnessed, for instance, a German POW crumble in humility when an American soldier took offense at a remark and punched the German in the face, kicked him, and then lashed him to a jeep in the hot sun for a day in North Africa, causing the young German suddenly to lose all of his Nazi indoctrination literally overnight and become docile.

Similarly, he had witnessed the Japanese kamikaze pilots toward the end of the war deliberately miss American ships which their mission demanded they hit and ditch in the drink so that they could be rescued rather than suffer death for a place in Nirvana. The Japanese had quit the war quickly after the atom bombs were dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, did not, as promoted prior to that time and as urged by the Emperor, stand fast for Japan to the last man, woman, and child.

He concludes that while he could not say who the best or worst soldiers in the world were, he knew who had won all the wars fought by the U.S., including the Civil War. And he adds that he was aware that General Grant drank excessively.

A piece from the Associated Press tells of the upcoming primaries which would fairly indicate the strength of the Fair Deal across the country in advance of the fall mid-term elections. In Oklahoma, a runoff would take place between incumbent Senator Elmer Thomas and his challenger, Congressman Mike Monroney, who had won the first primary, albeit by less than a majority. In Arkansas, the gubernatorial race had incumbent Governor Sidney McMath, a Truman Administration supporter, opposed by former Governor Ben Laney, a Fair Deal detractor and leader of the Dixiecrats. And in Louisiana, Senator Russell Long was trying to win a full term in the seat he had won in a special election in 1948.

In each of these races, the Fair Deal had become an issue raised by the challengers, or, in the case of the Thomas-Monroney race, a challenge to Senator Thomas's cost-cutting on defense as chairman of the Appropriations Military subcommittee, claimed by Mr. Monroney as contributing to the unpreparedness for fighting in Korea.

A letter writer encloses a letter he had written to the Raleigh News & Observer in response to a reprinted editorial in the News from the News & Observer, titled "A Little Far", originally published July 12, regarding a dispute in Burke County for alleged infractions by private car-poolers of franchise rights to buses granted by the State Utilities Commission. He complained in his letter that the editorial had done great damage, as it criticized the SUC despite it trying to eliminate the cause of automobile accidents in the state since the repeal of the vehicle inspection law in 1949 after a two-year experiment.

A letter writer opposes intervention in Korea because, he finds, Asians did not like white people in Asia.

A letter writer agrees with the editorial, "The McCarthy Episode Ends", and finds Senator McCarthy's smear tactics unbecoming of any citizen, especially so while hiding behind Congressional immunity. She finds it "shameful and unjust" that the persons whose reputations he had harmed would have to live with the stigma for the rest of their lives.

Framed Edition
[Return to Links
Page by Subject] [Return to Links-Page by Date] [Return to News<i><i><i>—</i></i></i>Framed Edition]
Links-Date Links-Subj.