The Charlotte News

Monday, December 8, 1947

THREE EDITORIALS

Site Ed. Note: The front page reports that in London at the foreign ministers conference, Soviet Foreign Commissar V. M. Molotov provided that the price of assent by Russia to economic unification of Germany, as championed by Secretary of State Marshall, was the previously stated demand of ten billion dollars from Germany in reparations and repeal of the economic merger of the American and British zones.

The previous night, Secretary Marshall had met with French Foreign Minister Georges Bidault and British Foreign Secretary Ernest Bevin, presumably to consolidate their positions. Theretofore, Secretary Marshall carefully had refrained from participation in any such separate negotiations among the three Western powers, apart from Russia.

In Paris, a scheduled walkout by subway and bus workers, as part of the nationwide strike by the Communist-dominated General Confederation of Labor, was called off because the strike was a failure. Likewise, a strike of Government workers was having limited success.

It was anticipated that the House would pass the emergency aid bill for France, Italy, and Austria this date or the following day.

In Oak Ridge, Tennessee, workers at the atomic energy plant were negotiating for a 25-cent wage increase per hour, threatening to strike within 24 hours if the demand was not met.

Senator William Knowland of California revealed that American diplomatic and military officials in Rumania had suffered searches by the Government of their homes and automobiles by Rumanian secret police. Apparently the searches had occurred prior to September 20 and appeared the result of Rumanian concern that a break in diplomatic relations with the U.S. was imminent.

The Senate began consideration of the Inter-American Treaty formed in Rio de Janeiro the previous August.

The Agriculture Department estimated that the year's cotton crop would be 11.69 million bales, an increase of 180,000 bales over the previous month's estimate, and three million bales above that of 1946.

The President returned to Washington after his five-day Florida vacation. Staff remarked that his Saturday speech on the dedication of the Everglades National Park was designed to keep politics to a minimum during the special session of Congress.

The Supreme Court, in Patton v. Mississippi, 332 U.S. 463, an unanimous decision delivered by Justice Hugo Black, ordered a new trial for Eddie Patton, who had been convicted in Mississippi of murder in 1946 and sentenced to death in the electric chair for killing a white man. Mr. Patton successfully had asserted that blacks were systematically excluded from the jury at his trial, as well as from the grand jury which had indicted him. The defense showed that for thirty years, Lauderdale County had called no blacks to serve on grand or petit juries, despite blacks constituting a third of the population in the most recent census. The practice of systematic exclusion of members of a given race from the jury pool, stated the Court, had been held for 68 years to deprive defendants of Equal Protection and Due Process pursuant to the Fourteenth Amendment.

Given the Court's decision, it did not need to determine whether, as contended, parts of a confession by the defendant had been coerced and extorted from him by use of force and intimidation.

The Court was about to hear oral argument in the case of McCollum v. Board of Education, anent a Champaign, Illinois, woman who was challenging as an atheist the religious education classes conducted in the public school attended by her son. She contended that the religious instruction violated separation of church and state, as provided in the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment, forbidding the Government from establishing a religion. The school district maintained that the non-mandatory classes, conducted by a religious council on school property, were non-sectarian, as the council was comprised of representatives from the Catholic, Protestant, and Jewish religions. The woman complained that her son was embarrassed by being the only non-participant.

Eventually, the following March, the case would be decided in favor of the woman, a concurring opinion of four members of the Court stating that in the field of religious separation doctrine, "good fences make good neighbors".

And to the deniers who persist in claiming that there is no such "separation" provided in the First Amendment, we again instruct on basic logic, that if the state cannot establish a religion, necessarily church and state are separate. It is no more complex than that, the complexity, if there be any, coming in the determination in close cases as to what constitutes an establishment of religion by the state and thus infringes the wall of required separation. It derives from the Founders' concern that a dominant religion, as with the Church of England, could be established by the Government and then lead to religious warfare. It is not to champion atheism over some form of religious doctrine. It is not to permit Catholics use of the public school buses to attend parochial schools, not an infringement of separation as held in the case the previous term, while allowing atheists to throw religion out of the public schools. That is not the point. Religious instruction belongs in the church or religious school, not the public schools.

Stop being dumb.

For the first time since partition of Palestine by the U.N. on November 29, there was no front page news this date on violence in Palestine between Arabs and Jews.

You do understand, dumbbell?

In Los Angeles, it was reported that new births would total 40,000, thirty percent higher than in the previous five years and twelve percent higher than in 1946.

Governor Gregg Cherry stated in Charlotte that progress in the state's mental institutions would enable 250 patients to be transferred to the new Camp Butner facility from the Caswell Training School.

A photograph appears of News Editor William Reddig chatting with the Governor.

The Carolina Farmer section of the newspaper tells of a Davie County farmer who had learned to derive, through soil conservation techniques, as much corn from five acres as had once been grown on thirty acres of his farm.

In Atlantic City, N.J., two women who had won the national open pairs championship at bridge discovered upon return to their hotel rooms that they had been robbed of $4,000 in jewels and furs.

The prize booty consisted of a beaver coat, worth $1,697, and a diamond-platinum bracelet worth $2,000. If you see that beaver coat or bracelet, snatch them back for the ladies.

The waterfowl season was opening in the state this date, but because of the decline in population of the birds, it would be 15 days shorter than the previous year. Better hurry and fire at will. But remember: the bag limit is four ducks per day and the possession limit, eight. For geese, both limits are one.

On the editorial page, "Soviet Holds Trumps in Germany" tells of the demand by Secretary of State Marshall that Russia explain by this date its position on a united Germany and what it would expect in return for assent to the Western position on that count being revelatory of the upper hand held by Russia on the matter, of central significance to success in rebuilding Europe.

The situation appeared simple to advocates of a separate treaty with Germany, to have one united zone for the West and leave Russia to its own separate Eastern zone. Secretary Marshall had never advocated such an approach, except as a last resort. But he was also aware of the heavy price to be paid to Russia for such agreement. His chances for success at achieving German unity appeared slight as the Russians would demand too much. But if Russia wound up with control of the Eastern sector, it would enable it to continue to seek to undermine the Western democracies.

"Poor Service to Car Drivers" tells of a bottleneck developing in the bureaucratic framework to serve the citizenry under the new law requiring a driver's license and motor vehicle inspection. The A and B alphabetic groups were being served for the latter six months of the year, and C and D would begin after the first of the year. The Highway Patrol was assigning a hundred more officers to the process.

That surely is a relief. You don't want to have to go down there and tire out your dogs every day for nothing. Get down 'ere early, C or D, crispy-frosty, on January 2.

"Six Years after Pearl Harbor" suggests that observers might be worried that the country was wielding the "Big Stick" following the war, as analyzed in another piece on the page by John L. Springer of the Associated Press. The junction in time which the country had reached appeared to be determinative of war or peace with Russia, its climax being the current London foreign ministers conference, following a series of stalemated efforts to conclude the terms of the peace.

Columnist DeWitt Mackenzie had asked rhetorically why the diplomats did not simply abandon the conferences and get about the job of ending the cold war. That, he posited, would be an admission of the existence of two worlds, which the diplomats were loath to confess. They recognized that the capacity of the nations to organize two worlds was beyond their means, that neither power had the military or economic strength to do so. It was madness to ask the world to choose between the American way and the Soviet way.

If the powers could reach agreement finally in London, then the world could rest assured that it was on the road to having experienced the last war in history.

A piece from the Greensboro Daily News, titled "What Is an Editor?" discusses the first meeting of the Conference of Editorial Writers, held in Washington, mulling in its first session the technique of editorial art or craft. The editors had determined that there were no standards for editorial writing, though there were for editors, who needed to be well-educated and in command of literature of the Great Books variety. The editor should have a sense of humor, have a knowledge of the law, understand countries abroad, as well as local politics. He or she should be well-versed in science, politics generally, tariffs, and taxation. And determined to maintain the spirit of changing the world each day with the editorial commentary. Complicated facts had to be rendered simply and in a straightforward manner. And finally the editor had to work for considerably less money than could be obtained in any other profession.

It suggests that it was thus no wonder that such a person was hard to find.

Drew Pearson tells of the romance of Madame Sun Yat-Sen, widow of the founder of the Chinese Republic, to American Army Captain Gerald Tannebaum of Baltimore having the Chinese Government worried for the fact of the veneration by Chinese, Communists and Nationalists, of Madame Sun. She was the sister-in-law of Chiang Kai-Shek, sister to Madame Chiang. She was regarded at high levels of the Kuomintang as the black sheep of the family for her advocacy of peace between the Nationalists and Communists. Some privately regarded her as a Communist. But publicly, she was considered a national shrine, with Government guards assigned to protect her. The surveillance had led to revelation of the romance.

The U.S. Ambassador to the U.N., former Senator Warren Austin, had risen at the conclusion of the General Assembly meeting to provide a salute to Secretary-General of the U.N. Oswaldo Aranha of Brazil, a close friend of the U.S. During the early phases of the war, he had convinced Brazilian President Vargas that the U.S. would recover its offensive capability and win the war, persuading him to provide to the U.S. strategic bases in Brazil. Mr. Pearson believes that Sr. Aranha deserved the Nobel Peace Prize for his efforts at the recent session.

The Army was balking at paying high prices for surplus dried fruits, dried eggs, sweet potatoes and peanuts, all valuable to European relief. The Agriculture Department argued that the prices would be beneficial to American farmers while supplying the needs of the Europeans. It appeared that Congress would need settle the dispute. Senator Carl Hayden of Arkansas had proposed that the surplus be made available to the Army at the same price per calorie as wheat. The Congress would make up the losses to the Agriculture Department.

Marquis Childs, en route through East Texas, tells of the sheep and cattle growers working to maintain the tariffs which had protected them for years from foreign competition. They were targeting the tariff agreements made the previous summer in Geneva, prefatory to the charter of the International Trade Organization, which represented a victory for sanity. The U.S. had made tariff concessions on woolen and leather goods, whiskey, pottery and other products. The other nations who were party to the charter made concessions on trade to open new markets for American goods.

The most important concession was that the British Commonwealth agreed to modify its trade preference to members of the Commonwealth.

The concessions by the U.S. were outweighed in importance by the concessions obtained, as imports could be absorbed in a time of great prosperity in the country.

A small minority of cattlemen were lobbying to eliminate current grazing restrictions on public lands, threatening the vitality of the resource to feed their own greed. They were in essence seeking to trade the land for a commodity which could be bought more cheaply on the foreign market.

If wool was so important to security, as the wool growers claimed, then the Government ought buy it in quantity and stockpile it.

Adoption of the ITO charter by the Congress was as important as approval of ERP. Renewal of the Reciprocal Trade Agreements was also essential.

In 1930, the Smoot-Hawley Act was passed, raising tariffs. It had precipitated disaster as nations followed in its tracks, raising their own tariffs, beginning the world economic collapse which led finally to the war.

Rejection of the ITO and failure of renewal of the Reciprocal Trade Agreements would be the equivalent of a passive form of return to Smoot-Hawley.

He urges that the small minority of cattle and sheep growers, acting for selfish ends, should not be allowed to lobby their way into defeat of the future peace of the world.

Victor Riesel discusses the launch in Washington of the new AFL PAC, dubbed the Educational and Political League. They believed that they could make or break a presidential candidate in 1948. They wanted Senator Taft to run so that they could engage him in a head-to-head debate on Taft-Hartley.

John L. Lewis, who started the campaign against the law, was now boycotting the movement of the AFL PAC, and waging a campaign against it. He was going to stop UMW dues from going to AFL and try to force the labor organization to expel the miners. His ultimate desire was to run AFL and when he had been rejected soundly by the recent convention from its leadership, it caused him to take a retaliatory stand.

Bill Hutcheson of the carpenters union also was boycotting the campaign against Taft-Hartley. He appeared to be headed toward becoming the Republican labor chairman in 1948.

The focus of the AFL PAC would be to get out the vote among workers. The committee would work quietly behind the scenes, with business agents working in the factories, homes, and union halls.

John L. Springer of the Associated Press suggests that the odds were now against a war with Russia. Since the American Revolution, there had been six declared wars and ten points of tension which ended without war. Rumors of war had characterized the country since its early days. He recaps some of the close calls, from the XYZ Affair with the French in 1798-99, the "54-40 or Fight" dispute with the British in 1846 anent the proper border of the Oregon Territory, tensions with Britain and France during the Civil War for rumblings of support for the Confederacy, the 1889 problem with Germany's claim to American Samoa, the 1895 Monroe Doctrine issue over Britain's disputed boundary separating British Guiana and mineral-rich Venezuela, the 1902 confrontation between Germany, for its aggression toward Venezuela, and TR, who coined the expression "speak softly and carry a big stick", through the 1916 punitive expedition into Mexico by General Pershing, chasing down Pancho Villa and his men for the attack at Columbus, N.M., on American citizens.

Yet for all the odds in favor of peace, it remained impossible to predict, in a given situation, what the outcome would be.

Framed Edition
[Return to Links
Page by Subject] [Return to Links-Page by Date] [Return to News<i><i><i>--</i></i></i>Framed Edition]
Links-Date -- Links-Subj.