The Charlotte News

Wednesday, November 7, 1945

FOUR EDITORIALS

Site Ed. Note: The front page reports that Chinese Communists had claimed victory over 70,000 Nationalist troops in fighting along the Peiping-Hankow railroad, as fighting increased throughout Shansi and Suiyuan Provinces. The Communists, fighting under the command of General Ho Lung, also claimed recapture of the Tzehsien rail junction on October 25. If correct, the Communist claims meant that the movement of Government troops along the Peiping-Hankow railway toward Northern China and Manchuria had been stopped.

The semi-official Government dispatch claimed that Red Chinese forces had breached the levee on the Yellow River near Taiyang in eastern Honan Province, flooding hundreds of square miles of territory.

In London, former Prime Minister Churchill expressed the opinion that the Soviets would not share the atomic secret if they alone possessed it. Mr. Churchill based his assumption on the fact that radar and other secrets had been shared with the Russians during the war without reciprocity. He urged Prime Minister Clement Attlee not to place pressure on President Truman to share the secret when the Prime Minister would visit the United States soon.

He assured, however, that there would be no effort by Britain to pursue an anti-Russian policy. "Nothing but a long period of marked injuries and antagonisms could develop any such matter again in this land."

It would be only four months until Mr. Churchill would make his "iron curtain" speech, sharing the stage with President Truman, at Westminster College in Fulton, Missouri, on March 5, 1946.

In Tripolitania, Arab violence and arson had erupted against Jews and Jewish property in the Jewish qaurter of Tripoli, as 74 Jews and one Arab had been killed and 83 Jews and 36 Arabs injured. The Arab League Libyans were seeking independence from Italy, of which Tripolitania was a colony, along with Cirensica. It marked the first time in the history of Tripolitania that there had been anything less than goodwill between Arabs and Jews. Leaders of both Arab and Jewish organizations were distancing themselves from the violence, expressing regret that it was occurring.

In Java, the Nationalist leader Soekarno continued to confer with British Lt. General Sir Philip Christison, but the discussions were not bearing fruit. The Dutch had offered dominion status for the Indonesians, sharing equally in development of the country, but Soekarno made it clear that only full independence would be acceptable. He suggested a division of authority between Indonesians and the British, that the latter could continue to disarm the Japanese and rescue internees.

Lt. General Nathan Twining, future chairman of the Joint Chiefs under President Eisenhower, was to be decorated by British Ambassador Lord Halifax in Washington as Honorary Knight Commander of the Military Division of the Most Excellent Order of the British Empire. General Twining, who lived with his family in Charlotte, was arranging transportation to Washington to receive the award. He had commanded the Thirteenth and Twentieth Air Forces in the Pacific and the Fifteenth Air Force in Italy, and in the last year of the war oversaw the attacks on Germany, Austria, and Czechoslovakia.

The 27th installment of the series of articles by General Jonathan Wainwright begins to describe the terrible days spent at Tarlac prison camp, as he and his officers were served only rice.

He read when he could, memorizing texts. He recalled in particular Oliver Wiswell by Kenneth Roberts, enabling him to escape his dismal surroundings.

The camp was enclosed with barbed wire but, even had they managed to penetrate the barrier, the surrounding mountains prevented any hope of survival for long. Nevertheless, they dreamed of freedom.

One day, the Japanese brought a scrawny cow to the camp. The craving for meat was so bad that the men sought immediately to corral the cow, but without success as it bolted and ran through the camp enclosure, eventually out the gate and into the hills. The men followed right by the armed Japanese guards who did nothing to stop them. Eventually, the cow turned and headed back into the camp, the men still following, the need for food overriding any thought of escape. Finally, one of the men was able to lasso the creature, which was then slaughtered, cut, and cooked, whereupon the Japanese took a third of the meat, the best parts, for their officers, leaving the rest for the prisoners.

In New York, Democrat William O'Dwyer was elected Mayor by a large margin, ending twelve years of Republican rule of the city. Mayor Fiorello La Guardia did not run for a fourth term. Fifteen of sixteen seats on the Board of Estimate, the city's upper legislative chamber, went also to Democrats. The election appeared to observers to signal a decline in the political fortunes of New York Governor Thomas Dewey—about as reliable a signal as the Republicans who were convinced even into last night, November 6, 2012, that Governor Romney was a shoo-in for election to the presidency, even refusing to accept reality in one instance once the call was made that Ohio was in the President's electoral column, clinching the election—a foregone conclusion actually for the last several months to anyone who bothered to look at the consistent polling results of the Ohio electorate during that time and realized its significance to the overall electoral count, never much really therefore in doubt, except at the Fair and Balanced Network, where you get all the Republican news first, after its having been filtered, that is, through the Rushing Lame-Brains.

As we said, Governor, if you had only promised everyone who wanted one, a brand new Rambler... But, no. Did you listen to our good advice? Nope. Went off with those nuts again on all that long settled junk, Roe v. Wade, 1973, and "conservative" this and "Ronald Reagan" that. And then, to top it off, the empty chair.

Now, where are ye? Loser city.

Newsflash: Ronald Reagan has not been President for 24 years. Romney-Ryan had a ring to it, but it was an old, old ring, and not a very pleasant one to many. Remember Dukakis-Bentsen.

Lightning rarely strikes twice in politics, decades after the first strike. It just does not work that way. The Democrats found that out, stopped in 1992 living in the past. Get over your unfathomable fascination with Ronald Reaganism, Republicans, and you might actually have a chance next time. Especially if you can last a whole campaign without once mentioning Roe v. Wade and by it, brand yourselves as the Party of idiots wanting to return to dark alleys and coat hangers, the 1930's, maybe adding a few lynchings in the process. At least, you don't talk anymore about "trial lawyers", Murphy Brown, "family values", the death penalty, "law and order" and that litany of other stuff you used to use to prey on the dim-witted.

Try, in short, running on a plan with substance, not cute winks, catch-phrases, and jellybeans. Believe us when we say that the American people as a whole, maybe with the exception of the majority still of the South and Midwest plains—who seem to think that it is still 1968 and the Silent Majority needs to have its say lest they take everybody's guns away, bus the children across the state to achieve integration, and put you in jail for smoking a cigarette—have long ago gotten beyond all that emotional salesmanship pitch "T" stuff.

In any event, congratulations to President Obama. Our conscience is clear, even if our precinct managed to knock us off the voting rolls completely, rendering us invisible, we suppose, even if Diogenes three weeks back did not think so.

A woman in Pittsburgh apparently threw her eight year old son from a twelfth floor window of the William Penn Hotel, then jumped herself. She left a note saying that she was beset by domestic difficulties and that she could not see her way.

And you thought your parents were flawed.

In Chicago, a seeing-eye dog, Tex, was injured when his blind master was struck by an automobile the previous night. The dog, obviously not having fulfilled his obligation to his master at the crossing, limped more than two blocks to his home to summon aid by barking and clawing on the floor. The wife of the blind man did not immediately respond and so Tex returned to bark again.

—What on earth is wrong, Tex?

—You were studying a dog from the neighborhood, Louisan, as she strutted by your eyes on the sidewalk, and so you didn't see the car? My heavens. What happened?

—Then Louisian was attacked? By Braska? Well, how is she?

—Under care of the vet. Okay. Okay.

—Oh, him, too, and he's lying in the street. Okay, we better get down there.

By the time the wife and dog got to the scene, the driver of the car which struck the man had taken him to the hospital.

Thanks a lot, Tex. You're a huge help.

The man wanted his wife to return to take Tex to the vet, and so she did.

We trust that Tex was sent back for some better training.

On the editorial page, "Farmer Bob Turns 82" discusses Congressman Robert Doughton of Statesville, chairman of the House Ways and Means Committee, one of two committees, along with Expenditures, which President Truman had singled out recently as having been dragging its heels in passing out of committee legislation to achieve full employment and expand unemployment compensation. Mr. Doughton was on rocky relations therefore with the White House and had even suggested to reporters that the President's cancellation of the trip to Statesville the previous week had been aimed at him.

Mr. Doughton had been in Congress for 33 years, had been chair of the Ways and Means Committee since 1931. At the beginning of the Roosevelt era, he was a solid supporter of the New Deal but in the latter years had returned to his more familiar home, championing fiscal conservatism, now bringing him into sharp conflict with President Truman.

The News had differed with him many times in the past and, predicts the editorial, would likely again into the future, as the octogenarian showed no signs of giving up the fight.

"Lewis and Murray Lose" describes the acrimony between John L. Lewis and CIO's Philip Murray at the start of the Labor-Management Conference, Mr. Lewis saying that he did not give a "tinker's malediction" whether he was a member of any committee.

Secretary of Labor Schwellenbach and Secretary of Commerce Henry Wallace were supportive of labor's contention that industry could withstand a wage hike without commensurate price hikes, based on the large profit margins developed during the war.

Industry's primary gripe was that it was of little point to engage in negotiations over contracts which labor would later repudiate, a charge to which the workers were susceptible with regard to strikes occasioned by jurisdictional disputes.

Just when it appeared the unions were to achieve a joint victory, the leaders were participating in inter-union squabbles, leading inevitably to loss of labor prestige.

"Of Fantasy and Fact" suggests that the only optimists left in the world were advertising writers. While they promoted the post-war automobiles, radios, refrigerators, clothes, and the rest, the stores still stood empty, a frustrating situation. Someone needed to impart to the citizenry that the new age was being postponed for a short time.

Whether from the desire of manufacturers to obtain higher prices after lifting of wartime restrictions or from labor seeking higher wages, the answer was likely not to be received well. "A frayed collar is as hard on the nerves as it is on the neck."

Someone needs to remind the nation in 2012 that complete emergence from the Great Depression did not finally occur until 1940-41 with the increased production in the country to supply the war effort. Emergence from miserably failed laissez-faire, trickle-down economics takes time. We are glad that the majority understood the fact and decided not to try to return to the past before the present has had a chance to work.

"Two Theories" discusses the support by Senator Josiah W. Bailey of North Carolina for a bill to provide five million dollars to study industries which could provide replacement employment for families who would be displaced by the mechanical cotton picker, the Rust Brothers machine, delayed in production by the war, now soon to hit the cotton picking scene. Maury Maverick of the Smaller War Plants Corporation wanted more funds devoted to such a program, including Government-insured loans to new industries willing to cooperate in raising wage levels in the South. Mr. Maverick believed that local purchasing power had to be raised to enable small, diversified industries to flourish in the region.

Whatever course was taken, something had to be done as the number of people who would become unemployed by the cotton picker would be large enough to cause a depression in the South, which eventually could spread to the whole country.

A little filler says: "A great laundry crisis is over in Havana, dispatches from there aver. Are we to assume the celebrated bar is hereafter to be known as Tidy Joe's?"

Yick Wo.

Seventeen years later, this filler would have fit far better the moment.

Seventeen years from this date, Eleanor Roosevelt would pass away in New York, the day after son James had been elected to his fifth and final term in Congress from California. Former Vice-President Richard Nixon had lost the gubernatorial race in California to incumbent Pat Brown. Congressman George McGovern of South Dakota, to become the Democratic nominee for the presidency in 1972, had been elected to his first of three terms in the Senate. Thus, it was a fateful mid-term election, on which turned, arguably, the political fortunes of the country for the ensuing 30 years, through the end of the Cold War.

Senator McGovern of course passed away on October 21, 2012, fifty years from that campaign and the sixth day of the Cuban Missile Crisis, the day penultimate to its being made public. His political fortunes, which had been waning prior to the crisis, may have been considerably improved by the President's handling of the crisis.

Of course, it was Senator McGovern who was running for the presidency when the break-in of the Democratic National Headquarters occurred at the Watergate on June 17, 1972, leading to President Nixon's resignation August 9, 1974. Would it were that the country then had the benefit of hindsight that it had two years hence, and Senator McGovern might have been President McGovern, sparing the country its "long national nightmare", as well some other things. In any event, we voted with Massachusetts on that one and have never looked back. Our conscience is clear.

Drew Pearson once again addresses the leaked secret memorandum on Pearl Harbor, as prepared in conjunction with the Army Board inquiry, the report which had been released in late August, prepared a year earlier.

He reports that the top secret memorandum stated that the Navy file no. 7001 had disappeared. It contained the logs of three Navy monitoring stations which had received shortwave broadcasts from the Japanese, allegedly containing the receipt on December 4, 1941 of the "East Wind Rain" weather report, the message meaning imminent war with the United States.

Regardless, the report stated that once Admiral Noyes had received the message from ONI of receipt of the "winds" message, he contacted Colonel Sadtler of G-2 on December 5 at 9:30 a.m. and Col. Sadtler notified General Sherman Miles, head of G-2, and Col. R.S. Bratton, Army intelligence expert on the Far East. Col. Sadtler was to return the call to Admiral Noyes to obtain the exact text of the message, but Admiral Noyes contended that he was in conference and too busy to talk to Col. Sadtler, would call him back later.

General Miles then contacted General Leonard Gerow, chief of the War Plans Division, suggesting that the Army in Hawaii be notified that, "War is coming and coming quickly." General Gerow responded that the Army in Hawaii already had plenty of information to that effect.

At Pearl Harbor, General Walter Short and Admiral Husband Kimmel had, on November 27, received the message that diplomatic negotiations were getting nowhere and to be prepared for war. Other messages were sent on November 28 and 30 to the same effect. Again, however, it must always be borne in mind that war preparation in Hawaii was mainly readying ships and planes for dispatch to trouble spots, not physical preparation for attack on Pearl Harbor itself, thought a remote possibility. If it was to occur at all, the principal fear was of submarine attack, not air. The primary focus was on the Philippines, Malaya, and the Dutch East Indies.

Another message was received by ONI on November 30 from Tokyo to the Japanese embassy in Berlin for transmission to Hitler, denouncing the November 28 modus vivendi of Secretary of State Hull—providing required terms for renewed economic relations with Japan, withdrawal from China and Indo-China and withdrawal from the Axis—and reaffirming the January, 1941 Tripartite mutual defense pact with Germany and Italy, providing that if war were declared on a member by a "neutral country", i.e., the United States, then the others would declare war on that country.

Col. Sadtler next tried to contact then Col. Walter Bedell Smith, at the time an adjutant to General Marshall, but he, also, believed that further warning to Hawaii was superfluous.

Col. Sadtler and Col. Bratton eventually were able to convince the War Plans Division to contact ONI and have them relay a message to Admiral Kimmel who would then alert General Short. But the message regarding supposed broadcast of the "winds" code never went through. (Again, there is no documentary evidence that the "winds" code was ever broadcast. Most historians consider it superfluous in any event, given the general knowledge that war was coming, even in the early fall, certainly realized by all, even the greater part of the press of the day, by late November. The $64 question was always precisely when and precisely where, an easy enough proposition after the fact to permit focus on why there were so many mistakes at Pearl Harbor. The notion that FDR deliberately allowed the attack to occur to bring a recalcitrant and ambivalent Congress, reflective of the pre-December 7 attitudes of the country, to declare war blinks the facts that the President could have sought a declaration of war on Germany or Japan for their unprovoked attacks on American shipping long before December 7 and refrained from doing so.)

It was the Navy's responsibility, continues Mr. Pearson, to do long-range reconnaissance around Oahu and Admiral Kimmel was not engaging in it based on the information he had received.

Then, late on the night of December 6 through the early morning, the 14-part message to Ambassador Nomura in Washington was transmitted from Tokyo, rejecting the Hull modus vivendi. It was being decoded at ONI as it was being transmitted. According to the Army memorandum, the fourteenth part was so hostile as to be regarded a virtual declaration of war. Nomura received a message in the morning from Tokyo to deliver the 14-part message to Secretary Hull "NM (noon meridian) PM", shortly before the time of the 7:50 a.m. attack on Pearl Harbor, 1:20 p.m. Washington War Time.

Samuel Grafton seeks to place under generic headings the reactions to the atomic bomb. First was the idea of outlawing it. Senator Kenneth McKellar had proposed this notion to the Senate, turning it over to an international commission per the recommendations of several of the leading atomic scientists who had testified to the Senate committee investigating use of atomic energy. The problem was that the nations without it would have to pledge not to use something they did not yet possess. The plea was tantamount to the United States seeking to uninvent that which it had been responsible for inventing. Senator McKellar lacked any proposal for making the world condition less conducive to use of such a powerful weapon. It could not simply be uninvented.

Another school of thought wanted to hide it. The President belonged to this camp. But the scientists had already disposed of this argument by asserting that the technology was already in the hands of physicists worldwide such that any nation with an adequate supply of fissionable material could produce the bomb within less than five years.

Then there was the "Aw Shucks, It Ain't So" school. Major Alexander de Seversky, author of Victory Through Air Power, and chief proponent of a strong air force for winning the war through bombing campaigns before sending in land forces, believed that the force of the atomic bomb had been exaggerated in its effects, that the fires which incinerated Hiroshima and Nagasaki were not from the bomb but rather from hot stoves. Mr. Grafton parenthetically inserts that perhaps therefore hot stoves ought be outlawed. Major De Seversky asserted that an atomic bomb dropped on New York City would do little more damage than a ten-ton blockbuster. (Perhaps, we should therefore ban video stores or internet movie vendors, or just tv, or just the Fair and Balanced Network on tv.) The Major did concede that the bomb was a "great step" in destructive force and it could be developed further in "great strides".

Mr. Grafton recalls, however, that without any hot stoves being contributory to the results of the blast, the desert near Alamogordo had been turned to glass by the Trinity test on July 16. Moreover, Dr. J. Robert Oppenheimer had, in response to Arkansas Senator J. William Fulbright's questioning, estimated that a single atomic attack on the United States could result in 40 million dead. That, quips Mr. Grafton, "wouldn't leave room for many great strides". Probably, then, would have to go to the moon, maybe Mars, to escape it.

"Maybe the Major is right, but to minimize the bomb, to consider it only a more powerful form of an old weapon, rather than a baby form of a new horror, is one way of fleeing from it."

Last in the topical analyses was "Squaring the Circle", an admission that there was no solution to the problem presented by the bomb, that world government was the most practical solution, but was susceptible to the charge that it was akin to jumping out a window to show that one likes fresh air. For, in the end, to explore patient relations with the allies and try to resolve differences amicably was fraught with the considerable risk of failure.

For to see Russia from one's window was not to deal with Russia and, who knew in 1945 that some, by 2008, would think that one could obtain the groundwork for experience in foreign relations sufficient to be a heartbeat away from the President, even twenty years after the end of the Cold War, by being able to see Russia. Harry Truman never went to college, but he knew that being able to see the Missouri River was a good bit different from navigating a riverboat along its course. For starters, one has to know what "Mark Twain" means.

Marquis Childs addresses the remarks made a week earlier by General Marshall in New York, suggesting that the country was undergoing demoralization, not demobilization. Mr. Childs cites the example that the Air Forces, which had been built up during the war to the most powerful the world had ever seen, with 2.5 million officers and men at its peak, was now without a single intact combat unit which could fly a single mission. The men with the highest discharge points had already been released, and they were the best pilots and gunners of the crews. By March 1, 1946, only 200,000 would remain in the Air Forces, with inadequate numbers of mechanics to keep the planes flying. Up to 90,000 planes would be destroyed, 32,000 of which were already headed for the scrap heap.

To fulfill U.N. responsibilities, the Air Forces needed a thousand long-range bombers plus 1,500 fighter planes, and that was the post-war goal.

Congress was reluctant to address the issue of universal training, advocated by both the President and General Marshall, as well as by the Navy. But the Navy was opposed to a Department of Defense to unify the Army and Navy under one civilian head. That debate had streamed into Congress, causing decisions to be waylaid by the uncertainty of the outcome on this critical issue.

"The rest of the world is watching closely. They see Uncle Samson as an involuntary victim of a heedless barber. He is being shorn of his strength while almost no one pauses to notice."

Maybe the same operative rule applied at Pearl Harbor, at Barber's Point... We shall have to consult our friend in the Caribbean.

A regular letter writer suggests that few Charlotteans realized how inadequate the police force was to cope with sudden outbreaks of large-scale lawlessness, such as in the event that bootleggers, armed with machineguns, might violently clash for control of territory. He had an answer for those who said that, no matter the pay, there would always be too few volunteers for police work to have adequate patrols. He favored a year of mandatory police training for young men over 18. It would educate the young to the problems of crime and vice, as they should be given courses in crap-shooting, beer-drinking, and prostitute hunting.

The communists, he warns, were gathering at Gastonia, stirring up the gangsters there. Time was running low. Draft the young men to police work, regardless of the Constitution.

Yeah, but what if it turned out that a good portion of those so drafted were bootleg whisky drivers or sons of drivers? Then you get that inside paradox, armed and trained in craps, prostitution, and beer-drinking.

Not a good idea. Let them go on to college where they can get the same training essentially, if they want it bad enough.

In fairness to Mr. Smith, whose ideas were usually sound, we have a feeling that he was being somewhat facetious. But it is a little hard to tell. He should have at least given us a hint, to separate himself from the ladies of the WCTU.

The president of the Dilworth WCTU, in another letter, wants the practice of Sunday movies discontinued now that the war was over, that the excuse for having them in the first place had been to entertain the soldiers training at Morris Field and Camp Sutton, as well for those having to work six-day weeks in war industry.

Since the movies did not contribute to the Sunday worship service, the ladies of the Dilworth WCTU had voted unanimously to bring the matter before The News, who they hoped would provide it immediate attention.

Yeah, but what if you were Jewish and believed that Saturday was the day set aside for worship? Then you've got no movies on Saturday either. And shouldn't the concessions be serving fish on Fridays? And what about the hamburger stands all over creation and Christendom? Shouldn't they be shut down completely? You have your work cut out for you, ladies. Better get cracking.

Lots and lots of problems...

Framed Edition
[Return to Links
Page by Subject] [Return to Links-Page by Date] [Return to News<i><i><i>--</i></i></i>Framed Edition]
Links-Date -- Links-Subj.