![]()
The Charlotte News
Thursday, July 23, 1959
THREE EDITORIALS
![]()
![]()
Site Ed. Note: The front page reports from Geneva that Premier Nikita Khrushchev had communicated a new threat of Communist action against West Berlin this date, placing pressure on the Western foreign ministers attending the Big Four foreign ministers conference. Mr. Khrushchev had said in a joint Soviet-Polish communiqué in Warsaw that the Western stand at Geneva might lead to aggravation of a situation "pregnant with danger to the cause of peace in Europe." The communiqué warned that if what it called the "abnormal situation" in Berlin, meaning the Western occupation, was not liquidated, the Soviet Union and Poland "will support East Germany in measures which she may recognize as appropriate." Mr. Khrushchev and the Poles repeated the original Soviet demand for peace treaties with the two Germanys and the transformation of West Berlin into a demilitarized "free city". They also repeated Mr. Khrushchev's threat to sign a peace treaty with East Germany should the allies not meet the Communist demands. That would provide the East Germans control of supplies to the Western allied garrisons in West Berlin, raising the threat of a new Berlin blockade. The new threat to use Soviet power against Berlin had brought some renewal of the tension which had subsided somewhat as the Geneva negotiations had dragged on. But Mr. Khrushchev and the Poles, perhaps significantly, had set no time limit for achievement of their demands, and the communiqué indicated that an agreement could wait for a summit conference. The Western foreign ministers and Soviet Foreign Minister Andrei Gromyko meanwhile were deadlocked in negotiations to find a way out of the Berlin crisis, with both sides declaring that they had no intention of backing down on key issues involving their basic and completely contradictory aims regarding Germany. Secretary of State Christian Herter had accused the Soviet Union of trying to hold West Berlin's 2.5 million inhabitants as "ransom" for an ultimate Communist takeover of all of Germany. The West, according to Mr. Herter, would never be tricked into becoming "an unwitting accomplice" of that end, again rejecting Mr. Gromyko's proposal that the German reunification question be handed to an East-West German committee with an 18-month time limit to obtain results. Western counter-proposals for continuing the Big Four talks on Germany had been rejected by Mr. Gromyko because, he said, they sought to impose a humiliating dictate on the German people. He insisted that the East and West Germans had to work out reunification as equals. The four foreign ministers had scheduled another meeting during the current afternoon to continue the argument, but the debate was overshadowed by the long-range diplomatic bombardment going on over their heads. The President, at his press conference the previous day, had said again that a summit conference had to be justified by progress at the foreign ministers conference, progress which would preserve Western rights in Berlin. Mr. Khrushchev, in the Warsaw communiqué, declared that a summit meeting would "undoubtedly contribute to lessening of international tension." He and the Poles had said that they considered the holding of such a meeting "highly important". When the foreign ministers conference had opened on May 11, there had been hope in the Western camp that Mr. Khrushchev would lift the threat to Berlin in exchange for agreement to hold a summit conference, but now, the Communists appeared to be using the renewed threat of action against Berlin as a whip to drive the Western leaders to such a summit conference.
In Moscow, it was reported that Vice-President Nixon had flown to the city this date with a plea for friendship, finding the atmosphere frigid, with Premier Khrushchev again blasting the U.S. for its attitude toward the Soviet Union. The two leaders had not met face-to-face, which would come later, but while Mr. Nixon was getting an official welcome at the airport, Mr. Khrushchev was talking to a Sports Palace crowd welcoming him home from his nine-day trip to Poland. He again took the U.S. to task for proclaiming the week as "Captive Nations" week and said: "They send their governors here, [referring to the recent visit of nine U.S. governors]. They send their Vice-President here. They are opening an exhibit here—and then they do a thing like this." Mr. Nixon's jet plane had brought him to Moscow in ten hours and 54 minutes. He had been met by First Deputy Premier Frol Kozlov, who had recently toured the U.S. on a similar mission, opening the Soviet trade exhibit in New York. The trip by Mr. Nixon was essentially an exchange visit, and the Vice President would open the U.S. exhibit in Moscow the following day. In his brief airport remarks, Mr. Nixon had warned that in another war "there will be no victors, only losers. There are grave and serious problems which divide us—differences which if not resolved could endanger the peace to which we are all dedicated." He spoke for about 12 minutes and about 100 diplomats had been grouped around him. A few American and Soviet flags fluttered in the background. There were no signs or slogans displayed as was customary when visitors from the Soviet bloc nations came to Moscow. Mr. Kozlov responded briefly and the interpretation was even more brief, with the interpreter saying merely: "The message is peace." Mr. Nixon entered a Soviet limousine flying the U.S. flag and headed out of the airport gates to the city and Spaso House, the residence of U.S. Ambassador Llewellyn Thompson, where Mr. Nixon would stay while in Moscow. There were about 200 Soviet and foreign newsmen present but only a small crowd of Russians at the airport, itself. As Mr. Nixon's car headed around the airport building, he spotted a large group of travelers, mostly Russians, on the plaza of the administration building and he ordered the car to stop, jumped out and began shaking hands. A small crowd had then collected around the car and Mr. Nixon, beaming, shook hands with everyone. Then he got in his car and resumed the trip to the city. His arrival had not been announced immediately either by Moscow radio or the television networks as both were using their facilities to cover a friendship rally for Poland then being addressed by Mr. Khrushchev at the Sports Palace.
The House Labor Committee, by a narrow vote of 16 to 14, this date formally approved the compromise labor control bill. Committee Democrats had split down the middle 10 to 10, and six of the ten Republicans had voted for the bill, which was a watered-down version of the measure passed by the Senate earlier during the session. Republicans had immediately served notice that they would fight to strengthen the committee bill drastically when it reached the House floor. Representative Joseph Holt of California had told reporters that "all Republicans who voted for the bill did so only to get a bill on the floor." Representative William Ayres of Ohio said, "Not one Republican who voted for this bill will vote for it on the floor unless it is amended by the House." The bill as approved was a product of five weeks of acrimonious drafting sessions, which actually appeared to please no one. In advance of this date's session, called to vote formal approval, there had been doubt that the compromise would turn out to be the legislation finally sent to the House. Lined up with substitute proposals were both Republican and Democratic members. Within the 30-member group had been members who wanted no bill at all, those who felt the Committee bill was too tough on labor, and others who felt it was not tough enough. Committee Republicans derisively called the bill a victory for Teamsters Union president Jimmy Hoffa, when it had been completed the previous Friday. After a secret strategy session on Wednesday, the Republicans had reported that they were prepared to make a fight for a bill with stronger enforcement provisions in the Committee's "bill of rights" for union members. The Committee version was a rewritten draft, containing over 100 amendments to the bill passed earlier during the session by the Senate. But the House bill had struck out the Senate's criminal penalties for violation of union rights and had substituted civil court injunctions against union leaders who denied members the exercise of their privileges.
A Presidential study commission said this date that many forms of U.S. economic aid abroad had to continue as long as the Communist threat existed. The group recommended more selective choosing of recipient nations, calling for creation of a new Government agency to be set up outside the State Department for administration of the major economic assistance programs. The President had sent the report to Congress, as a House Appropriations subcommittee had made public charges of waste and mismanagement in the multi-billion dollar foreign aid program, that report issuing on the heels of final Congressional action on a bill authorizing 3.556 billion dollars in foreign aid for the coming year. The study committee had been created by the President to determine the relative emphasis which ought be given to the military and economic aspects of the aid program and it was its third interim report. The mismanagement complaint from the House subcommittee had been a sequel to a long series of similar criticisms. In one unnamed country, investigators had found a 20-year supply of WAC clothing, a 45-year supply of .30-caliber carbine ammunition, 70,000 sets of new tire chains left outside without storage and more than a million new carbine and submachine gun clips wasting away. In Pakistan, U.S. aid officials reportedly had a fleet of 229 passenger cars, 529 refrigerators and 1,027 native helpers for a staff of 271 Americans. In Peru, a former aid official had testified that the U.S. aid chief had used American and Peruvian technicians to improve a livestock operation in which he had been a partner, the chief later losing his job. The testimony had been taken in closed sessions during May and June by the Appropriations subcommittee chaired by Representative Otto Passman of Louisiana, as part of its yearly review of the aid program. The report said: "Well over a million new carbine and submachine gun clips were found in open storage. They had deteriorated to a point where the major portion was no longer reparable. In the same command area there was a mountain of new tire chains estimated at 70,000 sets left outside without maintenance and storage… A conservative estimate of the loss due to neglect would run into the millions of dollars and excesses ranged from insignificant in the forward areas to 20 years' supply of WAC clothing in one depot and a 45-year supply of 30-caliber carbine ammunition in one school."
In Little Rock, Ark., it was reported that sophomores had registered at Little Rock's public high schools this date in the third day of registration, during which ten black students had enrolled for classes at white schools.
In Henderson, N.C., in the trial of the eight defendants charged with conspiring to dynamite facilities of the struck Harriet-Henderson Cotton Mills the prior May, the case had gone to the jury shortly before noon this date. The judge had provided the jury with instructions for nearly 2 1/2 hours, providing a detailed review of the facts and law relating to the case, saying it was "well tried and ably argued." The jury heard closing arguments the previous day after the defense had rested its case without offering evidence. The defendants, all of whom were members of the Textile Workers Union of America, including Boyd Payton, the Carolinas director of the union, were each charged with three counts of conspiracy, relating to plans to dynamite separate facilities of the mills, a boiler room, the headquarters office and a power substation. Conviction on the three counts could bring a maximum of 45 years in prison. The State had based its case on the testimony of a 32-year old unemployed machinist who had worked as an undercover agent for the State Bureau of Investigation. The State had planned to offer into evidence transcripts of taped conversations which allegedly contained the planning of the explosions. The State, however, had conceded that the recordings contained extraneous matter, and the defense would not agree to an edited version, prompting the trial judge to sustain objections to their introduction. The informant testified that he had been hired by the defendants as a dynamite expert, said that he had met or talked with the defendants at various times about the alleged plot. Defense attorneys attacked him in their closing arguments, with one of the attorneys telling the jury: "The State brought in an ordinary drunk and an ordinary thief and called him the truth... [The witness] likes to get people in trouble." He said that in 1947, the man had been convicted of stealing a police car and halting traffic by posing as a police officer. Another of the defense counsel had concentrated on a hassle between the State's witness and one of the co-defendants during a labor dispute several years earlier. The attorney also said: "There is a wicked, conniving, scheming mind behind this whole case. I don't know whose it is. Some mastermind directed every move—planting microphones, planting the SBI man…" The prosecutor, in his summation, had concentrated on evidence tending to implicate Mr. Payton and two other co-defendants. He told the jury: "I would hate to see these five lesser lights convicted, and those at the helm set free. It would be a shame and a disgrace to let the real brains of this thing smirk and smile at the law… Their convictions would do the labor movement in North Carolina and the South more good than anything." The TWUA had struck the mills the prior November 17 on the basis that management insisted on removal of an arbitration clause from the existing contract. Subsequently, other issues had arisen, including the job rights of the 1,000 strikers and new workers hired when the mills had reopened for limited operations on February 16, replacing the strikers. Violence had broken out at that time and the Highway Patrol had first sent extra men to maintain order, eventually necessitating the calling out of the National Guard in the wake of several acts of violence.
In Chicago, it was reported that a retired schoolteacher who had balked at paying a $20 traffic fine and had left the country while the City was trying to prosecute, was in the House of Correction spending 8.5 days to "work out" the fine. Calmly and repeatedly, the 72-year old woman had told the Municipal Court judge the previous day that it would be "against my principles" to pay the fine. The case against her dated to 1956 when she had been ticketed for speeding and failure to have a city vehicle license on her car. A traffic court referee had fined her $20 and the judge had later confirmed the fine, but she had disappeared during the 30-day appeal period. When asked where she had been since her last appearance, she said she had covered Scandinavia, France, Austria and Russia twice. She said that she would pick up where she had left off, indicating that she had not been speeding and was positive of that, that it was thus against her principles to pay the fine. She said she had not purchased vehicle stickers because she figured she had money coming from the "payless paydays" of the early depression years. At that time, the city had been short of cash and paid municipal employees in scrip. A Federal loan had later enabled the city to redeem the scrip with legal tender. The judge pleaded with her to pay the fine, saying said that he would dig down and pay the fine himself, instead of sending her to jail, but that it had gone beyond that point at present. She thanked him but said she was sorry that they could not agree. The previous night in the jail, she had given matrons a hard time when they sought to urge her to eat a dinner of hamburger, potatoes, salad and milk. The night matron said that they had pleaded with her to eat something but she wanted them to send out for something, offering to pay for it, but it was against the rules. They had finally gotten her to eat a bite of Polish sausage, but she would not even have a glass of milk.
In Long Beach, Calif., it was reported that Terry Huntingdon, 19, a coed from Mount Shasta, Calif., had been selected as Miss USA to contest for the Miss Universe pageant crown this night along with 33 foreign entrants in the ninth annual international beauty contest. The UCLA dance major had blue-green eyes, stood 5 feet, 6.5 inches in height and had measurements of 36-23-36. She had been selected the previous night before 4,000 spectators. Her roommate at the pageant, Miss Sweden, had shouted in Swedish her approval when her victory was announced, roughly translated as "She's a beauty." She was so happy for her roommate that she cried. The winner said that she wanted to become a dance instructor for a few years and then settle down and raise a family.
In Denver, it was reported that Governor Earl Long of Louisiana had given a strip teaser, Tempest Storm, the cold shoulder the previous night. He had a "date" with her at 11:00 p.m. as a Denver nightclub patron and Miss Storm had been on hand to present her show, but Mr. Long, 63 was dozing in his hotel suite.
On the editorial page, "New Sources of Municipal Revenue Must Be Found by the City" finds that many residents of the city believed that the City Council, with expert assistance, might have fashioned a leaner municipal tax rate for 1960. It suggests that the discontent would become more audible when it became known in dollars and cents exactly what the bad news was. There was reason to believe that another modest reduction could have been made in the $2.06 figure finally agreed on during the week. An eleventh hour effort to trim another penny from the rate had been initiated on Monday by two members of the Council, including Mayor James Smith, but in vain.
It suggests that the solution did not lie in any heavy-handed tinkering with service charges, such as water-sewer rates, to produce "profits", that the additional money which was needed in the future would probably have to come from wholly new forms of municipal taxation, requiring much careful study and consideration. It suggests that the time to start was the present, while budgetary problems were fresh in the Council's mind and when another round of budget meetings was still nearly a year away. It indicates that if a study group were put to work at once, the Council would be prepared to plot Charlotte's fiscal future in 1960 as it had not been, through no fault of its own, in 1959, and that such a move might serve to muffle the present bleats and cries from the man in the barrel.
"The Geneva Talks Are Petering Out" indicates that after eight weeks of gab, the printed transcript of which had to run to considerable weight, the Geneva talks were plainly petering out. Mr. Gromyko's smile, held as a hopeful sign at the beginning, had dissolved into the familiar stare of a stalker waiting for its prey to bolt. The President was pessimistic and the public was bored.
The situation gave rise to the question of why the delegates did not pack their suitcases and give it up as a bad try. That could prove to be the result anyway, and perhaps a desirable one, unless frankness would begin to prevail on both sides of the bargaining table. It does not know what had been whispered behind locked doors, but as far as public releases were concerned, it was clear that everyone had shied away from being impolitely frank.
At the beginning, it now appeared that both sides had been playing the game of excessive politesse, whether intentionally or not. The Western ministers were evidently convinced that the Russians wanted a summit conference so badly that they only needed to sit tight and smile until Mr. Gromyko offered the right price, such as reunification of Germany by "free" elections. The Russians had played a game of double-meaning on the Berlin "ultimatum", first affirming, then denying, that it was an invitation to get out of Berlin or else. It appeared that neither side wished to bargain at all.
Every move had been not a concession but rather a statement of an Eastern or Western stand-pat policy wrapped in conciliatory language. The Russians had "offered", to take the latest example, to set up an "all-German commission" on German reunification. That meant the de facto recognition of East Germany by the West, which appeared to be their real aim. The U.S. had adamantly refused to recognize the East German government and thus had resisted the Russian effort to allow the East Germans to participate directly in the conference on an equal footing with the West German Government. The Western powers, in return, had of late "offered" to transform the Big Four conference, or its equivalent, into a "permanent commission", which meant that it was offering to perpetuate the present talks as a substitute for change, since the West had chosen to have no program.
It suggests that perhaps the public
would be advised to keep its nose out of the situation, but the
commonplace observer was not so doped or yet so bored to fail to see
that neither frankness nor the spirit of barter had come into being
in Geneva. "Tin Pan Alley crooned it long ago: When an
irresistible force meets an immovable object
"Anybody for Political Name-Calling?" indicates that Republican propagandists were reported to be looking for an effective tag to hang around Senator Lyndon Johnson's and Speaker Sam Rayburn's necks. Still smarting under the "Do Nothing" label, which President Truman had pinned on the 80th Congress for purposes of the 1948 campaign, House Republican Minority Leader Charles Halleck of Indiana had first thought up "Won't Do" Congress. But he had become skeptical about that label as it appeared that Senator Johnson planned to keep Congress in session until it would do at least something. Representative Peter Frelinghuysen of New Jersey had suggested, "Have Not Done" Congress, but that also could prove temporary.
It indicates that it did not want to give aid and comfort to Republicans, but in sympathy, it wishes to try to help them bail out of their semantic troubles with something like, "Have Not Done But May Do Yet" Congress. It also might prove ephemeral such that something yet longer was required, such as, "Have Not Done But Would Have Liked To Do If Ike Would Have Let It" Congress.
A piece from the Miami Herald, titled "A Nature Story in the Raw", indicates that the roaring asphalt of a superhighway was no place for a family of quail. But there had been a hen and four chicks no bigger than the end of one's thumb which had emerged from the shrubbery to cross the S. Dixie Highway. The road had been empty at the time as cars were waiting at red lights like racehorses at the starting gate. The mother quail had stepped onto the pavement and her offspring had followed, single file, as they were accustomed to doing in threading their way through tall grass. All five were strung across three traffic lanes when the signal had changed and the cars leaped forward, thundering down on the tiny family. The mother quail had reached the center of the parkway and the little ones had panicked, circling, then fleeing back to the shrubs. The mother watched, sundered from them by deadly cars.
Few drivers had seen the quail, and traveling at 45 mph, they had passed the spot in a fraction of a second. The motorists who had terrified the quail would never know whether the little ones had been reunited with the mother and whether they had made it safely to the other side of the road.
It indicates that the busy highway was no place for a family of quail and it would be bad for a human mother with four young children. "Such steambeds of asphalt and concrete are strictly for torrents of traffic. They're unfit for beast or man."
Well, what are the highway planners supposed to do, establish quail crossings? Quails are supposed to quail, anyway, aren't they?
Drew Pearson indicates that when the President had lit into what he called the "Munitions Lobby" recently, he had probably not realized that he was hitting rather close to home, as one of the most powerful munitions lobbies in Washington was the AVCO Manufacturing Co., of which his golfing-bridge-farming partner, George Allen, was a director. In addition, AVCO was close to Secretary of Agriculture Ezra Taft Benson and employed a battery of key generals and admirals, some of whom were presently being investigated by Louisiana Congressman Edward Hebert's Armed Services subcommittee. Those included General Clarence Irvine, former deputy chief of staff of the Air Force in charge of material. In that job, he was top dog for all Air Force procurement, production and maintenance in the field. Since the Air Force planned for about a decade ahead, General Irvine was in the position to use that knowledge while presently working for AVCO. Another was Maj. General Herbert Jones, the adjutant general of the Army, who had stepped from that key post into AVCO. Another was Brig. General Munro McCloskey of the Air Force and yet another was Admiral Edward Woodyard of the Navy.
One way or the other, through friends or otherwise, the AVCO Corp. was able to roll up a total of 102 million dollars worth of defense orders in 1958, and according to Moody's Industrial Manual, AVCO's backlog of defense orders in December, 1958 had totaled 99 million dollars. Three months later, however, the backlog of defense orders had zoomed to 300 million dollars, and since the total defense orders for the preceding year were only 102 million, something had really given a lift to AVCO's business. General Irvine, formerly in charge of Air Force material and procurement, had joined the company in the spring.
AVCO was a far-flung company which manufactured everything from farm machinery to aviation engines to electronics to hydraulic loaders and chemical spreaders. It had factories in Coldwater, O., Fort Dodge, Ia., Williamsport, Pa., Cincinnati, Richmond, Ind., Avondale, O., Everett, Mass., and Chicago. Its chairman was Victor Emmanuel, who had been a guest at the President's stag parties.
Significantly, in the rush of contracts which had helped swell AVCO's profits, there had been some sloppy negotiating on the part of the Air Force and as a result, AVCO had been forced to make refunds. On March 19, 1959, AVCO had refunded more than 1.1 million dollars to the Air Force as a result of an error in the cost of a 15 million dollar Air Force contract for B-52 parts. It had been explained that the error had resulted from the fact that the Air Force had accepted more than 1 million dollars of recorded costs which the contractors included in error. The actual fact was that the General Accounting Office had caught the error, not AVCO or the Air Force. Without prodding from the accounting arm of Congress, GAO, the error might never have been discovered.
Joseph Alsop indicates that at the height of Napoleon's power, when half the thrones of Europe had Bonapartes on them, the Emperor's tough old mother had been heard to mutter, "Pourvu que ca dure!" translated, "Provided this just lasts!" or "Let's hope this just lasts!" He finds it worth telling because it conveyed the state of mind of Vice-President Nixon at the moment of his much-publicized departure for Moscow to open the American exhibit at the international trade fair.
Mr. Nixon appeared to have no doubts about the Moscow trip, having told people in Washington that he genuinely hoped to accomplish something by face-to-face straight talk with Premier Khrushchev. He had said that Mr. Khrushchev might be persuaded to see American policy in a new light by a man like himself, who joined in all the American Government's highest level policy reasons and could explain the reasons for him. Mr. Alsop finds it, however, a distinctly optimistic view.
The state of his domestic political fortunes absorbed the Vice-President and it was where he reportedly displayed the carefully conditional optimism of Napoleon's mother. On the surface, there was no reason why the Vice-President should not look forward to receiving the Republican presidential nomination in 1960 with absolute confidence. In most of the state organizations, Mr. Nixon's nomination was already being taken for granted and in consequence of that prospect, he was having great difficulty avoiding the uncomfortable role of arbiter in states where the Republican Party was divided.
Being sure that he would inherit party leadership, leaders of the contending factions in those states were pressing their own delegate slates on him, wanting him to recognize their faction by approving the faction's slate. Mr. Nixon had run into that encouraging type of trouble with special acuteness in Wisconsin and Pennsylvania, but even in other states where the Old Guard-modern Republican split was much less deep, the same sort of thing had been happening. He finds that there could be no stronger sign of the prosperity of Mr. Nixon's candidacy, and what made that prosperity more striking was the additional fact that Mr. Nixon had not yet put together even the shadow of a campaign organization.
During the previous year, he had added two able recruits to his personal staff, Robert Finch, former Los Angeles County chairman, who handled the Vice-President's political correspondence, and Herbert Klein, a Southern California editor who was serving in public relations. But even now, the staff was hardly larger than the staff of any well-heeled Senator from a major state. There was no one to take the road on Mr. Nixon's behalf and everything depended on the candidate's long-nurtured close links with the Republican leaders throughout the country. Furthermore, it was much more common for the delegate-owners to seek out Mr. Nixon than to be sought out by him. Under those circumstances, a less prudent man would have no doubts at all about the future.
Probably, Mr. Nixon, himself, would have no doubts, at least about the nomination, provided his own polls did not suggest that certain Democratic candidates would be disturbingly hard to defeat, among whom was Senator John F. Kennedy of Massachusetts, being the most conspicuous of those candidates, with more than 60 percent of the total vote in at least one of the big states which had been polled.
Mr. Nixon believed that he could overcome even such a lead as that after the campaign had started in earnest, but also foresaw that the Republicans would be extremely restive if the following spring's public opinion polls still showed Senator Kennedy or any other Democrat with such an enormous lead. The length of the lead would make the situation a setup for the use of the "cannot win" slogan, which had beaten Senator Robert Taft in 1952. Thus far, Mr. Nixon had been protected against the "can't win" slogan by one fact, that since around February, the other conceivable Republican contender, Governor Nelson Rockefeller of New York, had made a poorer showing in the polls than the Vice-President.
Mr. Alsop supposes that Governor Rockefeller would emerge from his self-imposed isolation, as he was showing signs of doing, and that he would embark on cross-country baby-kissing, mingled with statesmanlike oratory, as some of the men around the Governor were urging him to do. Then everything could perhaps change and Mr. Nixon could have a real fight ahead of him, even at the Republican convention, which at present seemed sewed up in his favor.
Walter Lippmann indicates that among the many big questions posed by the steel strike, perhaps the most important was what ought be the role of the Federal Government, as there was great confusion about it. The strike was taking place just as Congress was working on a law for the regulation of labor unions, which called for comprehensive and far-reaching Federal intervention in the internal affairs of unions. Yet regarding the steel strike, there were many, including now the President, himself, who wanted no Federal intervention and wished to see the issue settled by the test of economic power.
The President's views on intervention in the steel strike had crystallized only recently. A month earlier, at his press conference of June 17, he had been asked a question by Raymond Brandt of the St. Louis Post Dispatch: "Both the steel management and the steel unions are using self-serving statistics which are in great conflict. Is there any way that government can bring out some impartial figures on profits and wages and productivity so that people can understand the issues and make their own decision?" The President had answered the question by saying: "Well, I think you have asked about the most intelligent question on that particular question, particular matter; and I haven't thought about it in this particular way… I don't know whether this would be helpful or not, but I'll take your suggestion and have it studied."
The previous week at his press conference on July 15, the President had had the matter studied and had learned that "as far as a fact-finding board is concerned, I believe that all the facts are pretty well known… In all our reports, in the labor statistics and the commerce and the other figures that are published, some quarterly, some monthly, they are all there…"
Mr. Lippmann indicates that whoever had done the study of the question for the President had not understood the question or did not wish the President to understand it, as while it might be true that the "facts" were "all there" in some of the many reports which had been published, the public could not know as neither could Congress or the newspapers know which of those facts were important and relevant. The task of finding the facts which mattered and of judging how they mattered was a semi-judicial function which could not be accomplished without a specialized inquiry by trained minds. If there was no impartial tribunal to find the facts, then there could be no such thing as an enlightened public opinion and if that was the case, a strike of the magnitude of the steel strike had to become a test of power in a world of propaganda and prejudice.
When the President had rejected the idea of "fact-finding", of which he had thought well a month earlier, he had affirmed a new doctrine: "I believe that we have got thoroughly to test out and to use the method of free bargaining." But Mr. Lippmann questions how much free bargaining could be believed in where great and vital interests were involved. In the steel controversy, the companies happened to have the stronger bargaining position, their customers having large stockpiles, public opinion being opposed to another round of wage and price increases, while the union appeared to be far from solid within itself. But that favorable balance for the companies would not always be the case, and he wonders whether it was wise and prudent for them to set it up as a principle that in such great controversies involving the national interest, the issue would be decided by a contest of power.
He asserts that he did not believe it was true, as had been said recently, that it was "one of the ways in which freedom functions." For if freedom was to function, it had to insist that the struggle of powerful interests be regulated by rational and just procedure, and freedom did not mean that the powerful interests should fight it out as best they could.
"We live in a time when the vital industries and services of the nation are in the hands of giant companies and giant unions. We cannot entrust the interests of the nation to a combination of the companies and the unions, which is what we have had for some years until recently in the steel industry. Nor can we entrust the interests of the nation to a power struggle between the unions and the companies, however much the struggle be prettified by calling it 'free bargaining.'"
In such great conflicts, the national interest had to be represented and asserted by the Federal Government and the place to begin was by a clarification of the contending claims, as that alone might be enough to provide the basis of an opinion on which the Government could exert its influence and to which the public could rally.
A letter writer from Rock Hill, S.C., indicates that from where he sat watching summer television shows, it seemed that the repeat shows were bringing the performers into the house so often that they ought pay room rent. But despite the repeats airing repeatedly, a beach hotel owner had told him that he had to install a TV set in his lobby to ease the traffic jam. He bets three dozen steamed clams that he had seen one popular TV cowpoke shot in the same place twice each summer for the previous several years. TV broadcasters had a bovine summer schedule which left him with the feeling that, "Here it comes up again, boys." He suggests that perhaps it was the reason that the industry was fighting for pay-TV, that they could not get away with rehashed films if "Mom had to put a quarter in the machine."
A letter writer indicates that Mrs. Joseph McCarthy, in her letter attacking Richard Rovere, author of the biography recently reviewed in the newspaper on the late Senator, had "used the same guilt-by-association technique her late husband perfected so shamefully. McCarthyism certainly dies hard."
You haven't lived so long…
![]()
![]()
![]()